June 2005

Failure to adequately protect against the possibility of duplicate billing by carriers and payment by shippers:

Carriers make every effort to avoid these sorts of billing errors. Regardless of their best efforts, this type of error is not unusual. Well designed computerized freight payment systems have various types of built in duplicate payment checks, but even these are not perfect. A manual check for duplicates is better than nothing, but not very much, if there are a large number of bills being processed for payment.

There continues to be duplicate payment bills presented by carriers. Some of these are not a deliberate effort to double-bill but occur because of the manner in which the carrier’s particular billing system is set up.  For instance any computerized program can be set up to check for duplicate freight bills based on the PRO Number.  The computer can be set up to search for a set historical period of time, and to throw out any bills for manual review, which exceed the reasonable search-back period of the program.  But carriers may automatically re-bill if payment has not been received in 4-6 weeks or a couple of months, depending on the payment credit arrangements.  If the bill is re-issued an identifying letter may be added to the PRO number.  The computer is not smart enough to be able to read a carrier’s billing procedures and will automatically treat the number plus letter PRO as a new bill number and no duplicate review will catch it as a duplicate. So this bill will be paid! (A second time – or sometimes more often than that!) 

One other method of reducing the need for the program to search through a tremendous bank of historical data, is to set a time limit of beyond which no bills will be paid if presented more than 6 or 12 months prior to final presentation. Special handling can be given any legitimate bill that is presented in this manner, providing it is not past the statutory time limit for carrier billing.[1] The responsible implementing group is primarily Logistics with the others in the “Team Group C” with design assistance provided by “Team Group B.” 

[1]  See TRAFFIC WORLD June 18, 2001 on “Carrier Bullying”

 

 

 

 

 


TransAnalysis
291 McGowan Street
PO Box 5060
Fall River, MA
02723-0404

Phone: 508.646.1000
Fax: 508.646.1100