January 2005

Selecting a mode of transportation without regard to cost/service options

Often, decisions are made based on a perception that a simple rule such as "all shipments must be made within 24 hours"; must always be via air or some other premium type service. There are generally alternate less costly means to accomplish the same delivery or service requirements. For instance, many if not most over night air shipments going relatively short distance such as 3‑400 miles actually move over the road.

Many regional motor carriers provide next day service at greatly reduced costs. These same carriers could, if requested provide a delivery equal to many alternatives offered at highly inflated costs. Also, many shippers have an ingrained prejudice against intermodal shipments, but on the other hand, they also think UPS is great! UPS is one of the largest intermodal shippers in the world! Probably many a shipment by UPS has gone by intermodal anyway, but under the UPS label!  LTL carriers are developing "fast lanes" with guaranteed service or you do not pay the charges. (But be sure you review Action No. 101 for a thorough discussion on small package issues.) Service failures are expensive.

Finally, "ship next day" does not necessarily mean the best service! Sometimes waiting another day may permit a better LTL consolidation and in this process improve or equal service over the “next day.” very importantly reduces your costs!!  Importantly carriers publish service days between any two points, but these are NOT the actual transit times to expect.

Check your service needs, your costs, the available service, and then make your informed decision. You will be glad you did! Logistics personnel must involve all affected parties making the POLICY decision in this proposed action before implementation to insure that each specific responsible entity knows how their specific area will be affected and what the benefits are to be realized from the implementation. In the policy decision outlined above, the individuals that should be involved are identified in “Team Group A“.

 

 


 

 


 

 

 

 

 


TransAnalysis
291 McGowan Street
PO Box 5060
Fall River, MA
02723-0404

Phone: 508.646.1000
Fax: 508.646.1100